I’m putting the final touches on a super-sweet versioning plugin, and I’ve discovered that we’re using several different metaphors for configuring the plugin options. I’d like to get some opinions/feedback on your preferred style.

The DSL

Using a DSL and passing blocks in which get instance evalled. I’m normally very scathing of DSLs; I think that they’re Yet Another Language for people to learn to use – it’s usually your very own write-only syntax – but it’s been super-fun implementing the backend to this.

class Monkey < ActiveRecord::Base
  versioning do
    author do
      name { user.current.name }
      message { "Commited via #{name}" }
    end
    repository "Joe's DataStore" 
  end

Hashes

This seems to be the Rails plugin default:

class Monkey < ActiveRecord::Base
  versioning :author => { :name => lambda{ |u| user.current.name } }, :repository => "Joe's DataStore" 
end

Class vars / methods

Easy to monkeypatch later

class Monkey < ActiveRecord::Base
   will_version
   @@version_repository = "Joe's DataStory" 
   def version_author
     current_name
   end
end

Are there others? Which do you prefer? Currently I’m using all three in this one plugin, and it’s very un-awesome.